On a chilly morning in February 1930, a young astronomer named Clyde Tombaugh was hunched over a blinking comparator at the Lowell Observatory in Arizona, studying pairs of photographic plates of the night sky. After months of painstaking comparison, he spotted a faint dot that had shifted position. The discovery made headlines worldwide: the long-suspected “Planet X” had been found.
That dot became Pluto — the ninth planet, as schoolbooks would call it for decades. Yet, nearly a century later, the same question that drove Tombaugh still haunts astronomers: are there more worlds beyond Neptune?
The edge of the solar system
Neptune, discovered in 1846, is the last of the classical planets. But beyond its orbit lies a vast, icy frontier called the Kuiper Belt, a region teeming with frozen remnants from the birth of the solar system. These objects — icy rocks, comets, and dwarf planets — are relics from a time when the Sun was young and the planets were still forming.
In 1992, astronomers David Jewitt and Jane Luu discovered the first Kuiper Belt Object (KBO) since Pluto — a tiny world named QB1. That one find opened the floodgates. Soon, hundreds of similar objects were spotted, revealing that Pluto wasn’t a lone oddball but one of many icy bodies orbiting far from the Sun. Some of them, like Eris, were nearly Pluto’s size . That changed everything.
When Eris was discovered in 2005 and found to be slightly more massive, astronomers faced a dilemma: either call every large KBO a planet, ballooning the count into the dozens, or redefine what a planet is.
At a heated meeting of the International Astronomical Union (IAU) in 2006, the vote went against Pluto. A planet, the IAU decided, must both orbit the Sun and clear its orbital neighborhood — something Pluto, crossing Neptune’s path and sharing space with other Kuiper Belt objects, does not do.
So, Pluto was reclassified as a dwarf planet, joining a new category of objects that includes Eris, Haumea, and Makemake.
Story continues below this ad
Pluto’s demotion became one of astronomy’s most emotional stories. The public outcry was fierce. “When I was a kid, Pluto was a planet,” lamented well known planetary astronomer Alan Stern, principal investigator of NASA’s New Horizons mission. “In my view, it still is.”
Nine years later, New Horizons flew past Pluto, revealing a surprisingly active, icy world with mountains of water ice and plains of frozen nitrogen — proof that even “dwarf” planets can be complex and alive with geology.
Planet Nine: The Ghost in the Dark
If Pluto lost its planetary crown, another, far more mysterious world might soon claim it. In 2016, Caltech astronomers Konstantin Batygin and Mike Brown (ironically, the same Brown who discovered Eris and helped “kill” Pluto) noticed something odd: a cluster of distant Kuiper Belt objects all seemed to move in similar, highly elongated orbits.
The simplest explanation, they suggested, was that an unseen giant planet — perhaps five to ten times the mass of Earth — was shepherding them through its gravity. This hypothetical Planet Nine, orbiting perhaps 20 times farther from the Sun than Neptune, would take thousands of years to complete one orbit.
Story continues below this ad
No telescope has yet glimpsed it, and some scientists argue that the orbital pattern could arise from chance or the collective gravity of many smaller bodies. But the search is on.
Beyond Planet Nine: The Solar System’s outer limits
Even farther out lies the Oort Cloud, a vast, spherical shell of icy bodies that may extend halfway to the nearest stars. It’s believed to be the source of long-period comets that occasionally swing into the inner solar system.
If Planet Nine exists, it could mark the transition between the Sun’s planetary domain and this remote cosmic reservoir. Some astronomers speculate that there may be even larger, unseen worlds beyond, perhaps captured from other stars during the solar system’s youth — quiet, frozen interlopers drifting in eternal twilight.
When we will get to know
Our picture of the outer solar system is changing as fast as new telescopes come online. The Vera C. Rubin Observatory, set to begin its sky survey soon, will map billions of celestial objects with unprecedented precision. Many astronomers believe it could finally reveal whether Planet Nine — or something stranger — lurks in the dark.
Story continues below this ad
Meanwhile, missions like New Horizons, now venturing deep into the Kuiper Belt, continue to photograph ancient worlds untouched since the solar system’s dawn. Each image reminds us that the Sun’s realm is far larger and richer than the tidy textbook diagrams suggest.
When Clyde Tombaugh found Pluto, he worked alone, comparing glass plates by hand. Today, armies of computers scan terabytes of data searching for faint, slow-moving dots in the dark. Yet the dream remains the same — that somewhere beyond Neptune, another distant light awaits discovery.
Shravan Hanasoge is an astrophysicist at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research.
